Geography

Geography

Making clear of the most important convergence obstacles of Iran and Egypt's relationship(2018-2022)

Document Type : Article extracted From phd dissertation

Authors
1 Ph.D Student Department of Political Geography, Yadegare Imam Khomeini (rah) Shahre Rey Branch, Islamic Azad University,Tehran, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Geography, Central Tehran Branch Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Geography, Yadegare Imam Khomeini (rah) Shahre Rey Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Extended Abstract
Introduction
In the literature of geopolitical studies, the convergence of two countries has always been considered as their political, economic, and strategic intermingling. International convergences can both promote the geopolitical status of a country and expand its influence on geopolitical domains. Based on the status and functions played by Islamic Republic of Iran and Arab Republic of Egypt in the affairs of the Middle East, the existence of barriers to the convergence of the two countries can bring about considerably far-reaching consequences in this geographical region. Thus, the present study aimed to investigate the most significant barriers to the convergence of Iran and Egypt (in the period between 2018  and 2022). The study was applied in terms of purpose and implemented a descriptive-analytical methodology. The population consisted of all experts, specialists, and university professors in geopolitics and international relations, and Cochran’s formula(William Cochran)  determined the sample size at 50. The obtained means were analyzed using SPSS(Statistical Package for the Social Sciences). The results showed that transregional, regional, and domestic factors were the most significant barriers to the convergence of Iran and Egypt, and trans-regional factors were more pronounced in this regard. In other words, Egypt’s support of the intensified military presence of the U.S. in the Middle East, the Iranian ideology of exporting its revolution to the Middle East and North Africa, Iran’s support for the resistance front, and Egypt’s approval of “Abraham Accords” have had the most significant impacts on the increased divergence between Islamic Republic of Iran and Arab Republic of Egypt.
 
Methodology
The present study was applied-developmental in terms of its goals and could be classified as a descriptive-analytical one in terms of its nature and methods. As the goal was to investigate the most remarkable obstacles against the convergence of Iran-Egypt relations (2018-22), the data were collected using the library method and field investigations, including questionnaires, interviews, and field observations. The population of the study consisted of all specialists, university professors, and experts in political geography, political science, and international relations, and the sample size was determined at 44 using Cochran’s formula. However, the sample size was increased to 50 to enhance the reliability of the results. The sampling was performed using the snowball sampling technique. Moreover, the obtained reliability coefficient was 0.75, which indicated the acceptability of the results. 
Results and Discussion
The Islamic Republic of Iran, as a country with unique characteristics and a distinct status in strategic developments, is always influenced by changes and transformations in the international system and influences them in return. Undoubtedly, Iran is an influential country due to its special geopolitical, geo-economic, and geo-cultural features and plays roles much beyond a regional or local country. The Islamic Republic and the formation of a new attitude concerning the nature of the international system, the political issues of the Middle East, Iran’s strategies in opposing the U.S. as a hegemonic power, and the prioritization of the Islamic ideology in foreign relations transformed Iran’s relations with some countries, including Egypt. In the meantime, the gloomy relations, which originated from past occurrences (particularly during the 1980s and 1990s) between Iran and Egypt have been evident. Investigating the relationships between Iran and Egypt since the Islamic Revolution of Iran indicates that the relations have always been challenging. In general, the relations between Tehran and Cairo have been influenced by a set of convergent and divergent factors, and attempts to improve the relations through political solutions and diplomatic contact have been futile due to various factors and causes. Thus, based on the above points, the present study aimed to answer the following questions: what are the most significant factors in the divergence of Iran-Egypt relations as two influential countries in the Middle East?
 
Conclusion
The investigations carried out in the present study showed that the main reason that cut diplomatic ties between Iran and Egypt could be attributed to several factors, and all of them were divided into three major classes: domestic factors, regional factors, and trans-regional factors. In this regard, after presenting the results and descriptive findings, a variable was proposed based on the views of 50 experts and specialists in international relations, political geography, and geopolitics who filled out questionnaires distributed in the study. The results showed that trans-regional factors played the most significant role in the divergence of the relations between the two countries, and Egypt’s support of the intensification of the U.S.’s military activities in the Middle East, Iran’s policy of exporting its revolution to the countries of the Middle East and North Africa, Iran’s support of the Axis of Resistance, and Egypt’s backing of the Abraham Accords in the Arab States of the Persian Gulf and the Middle East had the most significant effects on increasing the divergence. Moreover, other causes included the Camp David Accords, Iran’s support of the resistance movement, increased socioeconomic relationships between Egypt and Israel, Egypt’s fears of Egyptians’ aggravated sympathies toward Imams and the family members of Prophet Mohammad, and naming a street in Tehran after Khalid El Islambouli. Nevertheless, any suggestions to facilitate the normalization of the relationships between the two countries require the elites’ will, particularly that of their top decision-makers.
Keywords

Subjects


  1. Akhbari, A., Akhbari, M., Mohammad Ismail Pouroshan, A., Ranjbar, M. &  Bahak, B. (2020). Hydropolitical analysis of the new structure of international relations (case study: Iran and Afghanistan), Geography and Regional Planning Quarterly, Vol.10, No.38, pp. 15-41. [Persian].
  2. Abdulmutalleb, A. (2016). Islamic revolution and modern regionalism in the Middle East, foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the Middle East region, Geography (Quarterly Journal of the Iranian Geographical Society), Vol.4, No. 51 pp. 501-522. [Persian].
  3. Bakhshayeshardestani, A. (2008). Iran's foreign relations in the international system, Tehran, Pelikan Publications. [Persian].
  4. Bayani, M. (2013). A comparative study of the evolution of Iran's position in Egypt's foreign policy before and after the victory of the Egyptian revolution (last decade), master's thesis, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Humanities, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran branch. [Persian].
  5. Darvishi Setalani, F. & Mozafari, S. (2018). Investigating the influencing factors on the divergence of relations between Iran and Egypt (1978-2013). Political Studies of the Islamic World, Vol. 7, No. 25, pp.1-30 .[Persian].
  6. Euronews news agency/ President of Egypt: If the security of the Persian Gulf is threatened, we will intervene militarily/ 2018/11/7.
  7. Faraji, M.R. (2012). Determining parameters of Egypt's foreign policy from Nasser's revolution to the army coup (1952-2013), Islamic World Political Studies Quarterly, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp 15-31. [Persian]
  8. Haqhshenas, M. (2017). Evolution of Iran's position in the geopolitics of Shiism in West Asia from 2000 to now, Master's thesis, Department of Political Geography, Faculty of Humanities, Mofid University. [Persian]
  9. Hussain, F. (2020). Geostrategic Imperatives of Gwadar Port for China.The Korean Journal of International Studies,Vol.18, No.2,pp. 145-167. https://doi.org/10.14731/kjis.2020.08.18.2.145
  10. Ghorbani, M. (2014). Examining the relations between Iran and Egypt; After the Iranian Islamic Revolution. Islamic Revolution Documentation Center, Tehran. [Persian].
  11. ISNA news agency/ Sisi to King Salman: Persian Gulf security is an integral part of Egypt's security/ news code 1400121713817
  12. Javadanimoghadam, M. & Shafiei, M. (2014). The paradox of convergence in the foreign relations of Iran and Egypt after the Islamic Revolution (1979-2014), Vol. 1, No. 1, pp.22-50. https://civilica.com/doc/856390. [Persian].
  13. Jafarivaldani, A. (2007). Iran and Egypt from competition to cooperation, Journal of Political and Economic Information, Vol. 1, No. 4 & 3, pp.18-33. [Persian].
  14. Karimi, M. (2010). The modern geopolitics of Turkey and its impact on the economic development of the Islamic Republic of Iran (case study: Turkey's accession to the European Union), Master's thesis, Department of Political Geography, Faculty of Humanities, Islamic Azad University, Faculty of Sciences and researches. [Persian].
  15. Kausch, K. (2015). Geopolitics and democracy in the Middle East. Fride, Spain.
  16. Mazaheri, M.M., Ahmadzadeh, D. (2009). Investigating structural challenges in the relations between Egypt and Iran, scientific-research quarterly of political and international research, Islamic Azad University, Shahreza branch, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 155-178. [Persian].
  17. Mousavi, S.M., Toti, H.Ali. & Mousavi, M.R. (2012). Iran's Islamic Revolution and Egypt's geopolitical developments (with an emphasis on the opportunities and challenges ahead), Islamic Revolution Research Journal, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 145-164. [Persian].
  18. Mahkooi, H. & Baveer, H. (2014). The role of regional organizations in reducing regional challenges, a case study: ECO Economic Cooperation Organization, International Organizations, Vol.5, No. 7, pp.137-161. [Persian].
  19. Mirahmadi, S. & Pishgahifard, Z. (2010). Geopolitical analysis of relations between Iran and Egypt after the Second World War, senior thesis, University of Tehran, Faculty of Geography, Department of Human and Political Geography. [Persian].
  20. Nasiri, M. (2007). Delving into the mutual influences of the cultural geography of Iran and Egypt, National Studies Quarterly, Vol.8, No. 32, pp.77-98. [Persian].
  21. Pezeshk, A. (2015). Positions and performance of political Salafi and Salafi-Jihadi movements towards the Islamic Republic of Iran (case study of ISIS and Hizb Al-Nour, Egypt), Master's Thesis, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Humanities, Imam Khomeini International University (RAH). [Persian].
  22. Qoloubi, J. (2008). The role of America and the Zionist regime in the political relations between Iran and Egypt, African Studies, Vol.13, No. 18, pp. 17-52. [Persian]
  23. Rahmanitirkalai, H., Sadeghian, N. (2018). Geographical scope of Islamic civilization, Geography (Scientific Quarterly of the Geographical Society of Iran), Vol. 16, No. 58, pp.191-200. [Persian].
  24. Sadeghzadeh, M.A. (2015). Opportunities and challenges of Iran-Egypt relations after the 2011 revolution, Master's thesis, Faculty of Political Science, Department of International Relations, Bagheral Uloom University. [Persian].
  25. Smith, A. & Hadfield, E. (2012). Foreign policy, theories, actors and case studies, translated by Amir Mohammad Haj Yousefi, Mohsen Mahmoudi and Ayoub Karimi, Volume 1, Tehran, Samit Publishing House. [Persian].
  26. Tabatabaei, A., Zarei, B., Kamran, H. & Ahmadi, S.A. (2022). Investigating the formation process of national identity in Iran, from the perspective of territorialism. Geography (Scientific Quarterly of the Iranian Geographical Society), Vol.20, No.72, pp.19-32. [Persian].
  27. Tabatabai, S.M., IsmailPourroshan, A., Daniyali, T. & Lotfi, H. (2020). Pathology of the perspective of the convergence of Iran and the member countries of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization: a case study of China. Geography and Regional Planning Quarterly, Vol.10, No.2-2, pp. 567-592. [Persian].
  28. The Young Journalists' Club/Sisi and Bin Salman emphasized the need for joint cooperation to deal with regional interventions.https://www.yjc.news/fa/news/6461207. [Persian].
  29. Vakili, F. (2013). Investigating the causes and contexts of the emergence and transformation of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, Master's thesis, Department of Sociology, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Razi University. [Persian].
  30. Wasegh, M., Ahmadi, S.A. & Tabatabai, A. (2018). Analysis of effective factors in the improvement of the border areas of Iran and Afghanistan from a geopolitical point of view. Geography (Scientific Quarterly of the Iranian Geographical Society), Vol.16, No. 58, pp.115-140. [Persian].
  31. Wilson, R. (2021). Economic development in the MiddleRoutledge, londan. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003053149                         
  32. Yousefnejad, E. (2005). bilateral relations between Iran and Egypt; Opportunities, Challenges and Future Prospects, Political Studies Office of the Islamic Council Research Center, Vol. 12, No. 49-50. [Persian].
  33. Young Journalists Club/Sisi and Bin Salman emphasized the need for joint cooperation to deal with regional interventions/news code 6461207. [Persian].
  34. Zarghami, M. (2017). Divergence of relations between Egypt and Saudi Arabia during the Al-Sisi era, Master's thesis, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Humanities, Mofid University. [Persian].
  35. Zebardast, Sh (2017). Investigating the political contradictions between Turkey and Iran in Syria, Egypt and Iraq between 210-2015, Master's thesis, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Political Science, University of Tehran. [Persian].