Geography

Geography

Explaining the role of smart transportation in the socio-economic development of the city (Case study: Tehran)

Document Type : Research Article

Authors
1 PhD student in Geography and Urban Planning, North Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Professor of Human Geography, Yadegar Imam Khomeini (RA) Branch, Shahr-e Ray, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
3 Associate Professor of Geography and Urban Planning, Yadegar Imam Khomeini (RA) Branch, Shahr-e Ray, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Due to the problems related to the provision of transportation infrastructure, the managers of the countries have decided to investigate the advances in technology in order to find a solution to overcome the transportation problems, and seek to solve these problems with a method other than the traditional methods of the past. (Jabbari et al, 2012). Of course, in the meantime, city officials are doing their best to achieve safe, fast, convenient and economical transportation, but "transportation" imposes a lot of social, economic and environmental costs and damages on the country due to the lack of a cross-sectoral approach and the inefficiency of facilities and equipment (Ahadi and Barimani, 2011), and there is a difference of opinion about the concepts of the nature of transportation and sustainable urban development or sustainable development in urban construction as well as the feasibility of that approach (Rezania and etal, 2017); while sustainable transportation policies seek to find methods that provide the possibility of proper access for all sections of society, adjust economic costs and reduce environmental pollution.
An approach has been considered with regard to the development of cities and special attention to the sustainable development of the city in the future that can help us in reaching a sustainable city and realizing the ideal of a sustainable city, and it is nothing but the smart transportation system approach. The smart transportation system (ITS) refers to a general term for the combined application of communication, control and information processing technologies for transportation systems that leads to saving in human lives, time, money, energy and provides environmental benefits (Tumlin, 2012).
Methodology
This study is considered to be applied research based on the objective and descriptive-analytical research based on its nature and method. The population of the research is Tehran, whose members were selected for study and investigation using a convenience sampling method. The data were collected using both field and library methods with tools such as: books, articles, theses, publications, statistics, maps, the internet, researcher-made questionnaires and interview cards. Cronbach's alpha method was used for the reliability of the data collection tool, and its value was 9.19. The studied samples were selected (100 people) based on availability and the knowledge and expertise required by a targeted or judgmental non-probability approach. The studied indicators were analyzed with the help of SPSS software (Pearson's correlation test and multiple regression) simultaneously.
 
Results and Discussion
The index and value of "average effects" have been used to measure the number of effects. In total, smart transportation has a medium to high impact on the economic development of Tehran and the average score of 3.35 confirms this. In the separate analysis of indicators, the greatest impact of smart transportation has been on the creation of side job opportunities, which, with an average of 4.13 is the only indicator on which the system has had a great impact. In the socio-cultural sector, smart transportation (internet taxi) has had a great impact on the quality of life of the city's residents by saving the time for citizens and passengers, strengthening their satisfaction with the living environment of Tehran and creating mental and psychological comfort, and improving the mental security of citizens. Additionally, this system has a relatively large impact on the spatial justice of the city; meaning access to transportation services and facilities at any time and place for everyone. According to the average results of "types" of transportation, the urban subway has had a significant impact on sustainable development (economic- and social) and is more smart than other transportation systems. Also, the effects of BRT buses and then internet taxis have also been observed at a high level.
In the section on the "Possibilities" of smart transportation, it should be noted that their overall effects were evaluated at a high level with an average of 4.25, indicating high user satisfaction. Some of the most important smart transportation facilities in Tehran include map routing facilities, online information to the driver regarding traffic, weather, accidents, and other relevant information, electronic payment facilities for: fares, parking and tolls and car and driver information report to the passenger, which has a very high impact on the development of Tehran. Furthermore, all smart transportation "services" have a significant impact on the socio-economic development of Tehran. The most important and effective tools and services of smart transportation in Tehran are route finders, location tracker app, traffic light control system,
 
speedometers and user notification systems. The most significant difference is observed in the evaluation of the effects from the perspective of the satisfaction index and the disparity in people's satisfaction with smart transportation has caused the di
fference in their evaluation in economic, socio-cultural dimensions. Moreover, there is a significant difference in evaluating the effects of transportation services and facilities from the perspective of their use of smart transportation.
 
Conclusion
The intellectualization of transportation infrastructures is considered an innovation that needs to be examined for the needs, structure, goals, power, and potential of each city in order to have a greater and more positive impact and development, and the appropriate system should be implemented based on these components. Comprehensive, diverse facilities and services that are appropriate to the economic-social conditions of the society and its people can play an effective role in the level of use and satisfaction of people and ultimately the sustainable development of the city. According to the survey results of the studied population's members (experts in this field), 50% of them believe that intelligent transportation plays a significant role in the sustainable development of the city. According to the same survey, this system has had a moderate impact (38 and 32% of the population) on the quantity and quality of roads particularly in constructing  (new roads and passages and in creating facilities and services on roads and passages based on this system; this is because 38% believed that the city's infrastructure and facilities are not suitable for this type of transportation.
 
Keywords

Subjects


  1. Abolhasanpour, A. (2008). Examining the impact of using intelligent transportation systems (ITS) on traffic flow improvement in Isfahan. Traffic Management Studies Quarterly, 3(8), 97-121. [Persian]
  2. Ahadi, Mohammadreza; Berimani, Manoochehr. (2011). Investigating the effects of traffic conditions on road accidents in Semnan province. First National Conference on Traffic: Safety and Executive Solutions, Kerman, April 20. [Persian]
  3. Ahmadi, Kianoush. (2020). Intelligent Transportation Systems. International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Development, and Urban Infrastructure Renewal in Iran, Tehran. [Persian]
  4. Ahmadi, Touhid; Teimouri, Razieh; Aghnaei, Fatemeh. (2018). Strategies for developing sustainable transportation in metropolises with an emphasis on intelligent transportation. Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Planning of Islamic Countries, Tabriz, May 9. [Persian]
  5. Ahmadzadeh, Tayebeh; Karkeh-Abadi, Zeynab. (2018). Examining the impact of installing intelligent transportation systems on reducing road fatalities: A case study of Shahroud-Sabzevar Road. Semnan Police Knowledge Quarterly, 8 (27), 9-29. [Persian]
  6. Alzahrani, M., Wang, W., Liao, W., Chen, X., Yu, W. (2024). Survey on Multi-Task Learning in Smart Transportation. Preparation of Papers for IEEE ACCESS, https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2024.3355034
  7. Anwar, A.H.M.M., Oakil, A.T. (2024). Smart Transportation Systems in Smart Cities: Practices, Challenges, and Opportunities for Saudi Cities. Smart Cities, and Studies in Energy, Resource and Environmental Economics, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-35664-3_17.
  8. Arjmand-Ziarati, Meraj; Salehi, Mohammadjavad. (2016). Examining the economy of urban transportation infrastructure. First International Conference on Urban Economics (Focusing on Resistance Economy, Action, and Implementation), May 19. [Persian]
  9. Asaf, Shiva; Rahimov, Kamran. (2012). The role of intelligent transportation systems in improving accident-prone areas: Case study of Karaj-Chalous Road. 11th Iranian Transportation and Traffic Engineering Conference, Tehran. [Persian]
  10. Ashraf, A. & Idrisi, M.J. (2024). Smart and Sustainable Public Transportation - A Need of Developing Countries. International Journal of Networked and Distributed Computing,. [Persian] https://doi.org/10.1007/s44227-024-00023-2
  11. Ashraf, S. A., Blasco, R., Do, H., Fodor, G., Zhang, C., & Sun, W. (2020). Supporting vehicle to-everything services by 5G new radio release-16 systems. IEEE Communications Standards Magazine, 4(1), 26-32. https://doi.org/1109/MCOMSTD.001.1900047
  12. Aslani, M. (2017). The role of intelligent transportation in urban management, planning, and development. 5th International Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development, Tehran. [Persian]
  13. Bakhtiari, Saeed; Asemani, Aidin. (2018). Proposing intelligent transportation through deep route in a smart city. 4th National Conference on Empowering Society in Humanities and Management Studies, Tehran. [Persian]
  14. Bikdeli, Sona; Shafaghi, Siros; Vosoughi, Fatemeh. (2017). Presenting a strategic model for achieving urban sustainable development in Mashhad metropolis. Geographical Research Quarterly, 32(4), 12-29. [Persian]
  15. Daryabari, S. & Hallajian, A. (2017). Effectiveness of Traffic Reduction Methods in Tehran Metropolis and Appropriate Solutions (Case Study: Region 2 of Tehran). Urban Management Quarterly, (49), 535-549. Retrieved from: SID [Persian]
  16. Dehnad, Seyed Mohammad Hossein. (2018). Intelligent Transportation: A Prelude to Smart Cities. Traffic: The Scientific-Professional Journal of the Qom Province Engineering Organization, 5(19), 76-78. Retrieved from: Dehnad [Persian]
  17. Estadi-Jafari, M. & Rasafi, A. (2012). Evaluation of sustainable development policies in urban transportation using system dynamics models: Case study of Mashhad. Urban Management Quarterly, 31, 281-294. [Persian]
  18. Fanaei, Hamidreza. (2014). Sustainable Development and the Role of Intelligent Transportation Systems. National Conference on Architecture, Civil Engineering, and Modern Urban Development, Tabriz. Retrieved from: Civilica [Persian]
  19. Fardineh, K. (2017). Intelligent transportation systems. 3rd International Conference on New Horizons in Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Planning, Tehran. [Persian]
  20. Firouzzar, A. & Ghorbani, M. (2011). Factors Influencing Citizens’ Willingness to Pay for Air Pollution Reduction in Mashhad; A Two-Stage Homogeneous Model Application. Scientific-Research Quarterly of Urban Management, (28), 7-26. Retrieved from: SID [Persian]
  21. Gaharpour, A. A. (2023). Prioritizing intelligent transportation systems to enhance road safety (Case study: Hamedan province). Scientific Journal of Roads, 23(116), 31-50. [Persian]
  22. Ghafghazi, I., Madani, A., & Hosseindokht, H. (2013). Economic analysis and feasibility study of implementing intelligent transportation systems (Prophet Mohammad Highway) in East Azerbaijan province. 13th International Conference on Transportation Engineering and Traffic, 6-7 Esfand, Traffic and Transportation Organization. [Persian]
  23. Ghanbari Pour, G., Afzali, K., & Barari, M. (2022). Assessment of a combined model for prioritizing intelligent transportation strategies in intermediate cities. Journal of Human-Built Environment Studies, 1(1), 273-298. [Persian]
  24. Ghodrati, A. (2006). Intelligent transportation systems. National Conference on Urban Environmental Accessibility, Research Institute of Engineering and Medical Sciences, Tehran, November 3.
  25. Ghorbani, M., Mousavi Ashkouri, S., & Reza Ali Khani, M. (2016). Implementing strategies for the development of intelligent transportation systems in the country. 16th International Conference on Transportation Engineering and Traffic, Tehran. [Persian]
  26. Habibian, M. (2012). Exploring the role of TDM policies on car commuters’ mode change: Subjective vs. objective approach. In Safavi, H. R., ed. 9th International Congress on Civil Engineering, Isfahan, 2012.
  27. Hadiqeh-Javani, M. & Estadi-Jafari, M. (2009). Examining sustainable urban transportation focusing on the development of public transportation. 9th Transportation and Traffic Engineering Conference of Iran, Tehran. [Persian]
  28. Haghighi, J. (2016). Investigating the impact of urban transportation on sustainable development and the environment: Case study of Mashhad. 1st International Conference on Integrated Management and Urban Economic Development, Tabriz, Ataturk University, Turkey, September 10. [Persian]
  29. Hajjarzadeh, M. (2014). Structural design of intelligent transportation: A necessity for benefiting from a modern transportation system. Tin News Industry News Portal.
  1.  
  1. Hashemipour, F., & Mansouri, A. (2016). Designing intelligent transportation systems with an emphasis on traffic management, case study: Bandar Abbas city. 2nd International Conference on Architecture, Civil Engineering, and Urban Planning in the 21st Century, Iranian Architecture and Urban Planning Association, Alana Architecture and Urban Planning Association, Alborz Province. [Persian]
  2. Hazeghi, M., Mirza-Aghaei, S., Rezaei-Gorgani, A. &  Ali-Mirzaei, M. (2018). Analyzing the importance of the role of intelligent transportation systems in transportation sustainability and development. Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Planning of Islamic Countries, Tabriz. [Persian]
  3. Hejazi, Seyed J. Touranpour, A. (2015). Application of Arc Map GIS software in the location of intelligent transportation systems in intercity roads. Advanced Applied Geology Journal, 15, 20-27. [Persian]
  4. Hejazi, & Jafari-Noimi Pour, N. (2011). Strategic planning for the development of intelligent transportation systems in Iran. 3rd National Urban Civil Engineering Conference, Sanandaj. [Persian]
  5. Herati, B., Darastan, K., Mojgan, N., & Hiyati, A. (2015). Examining the strategic role of transportation in the sustainable urban development of Zahedan. International Conference on Geography and Sustainable Development, Tehran. [Persian]
  6. Heydari, M. & Bagheri, Kobra. (2020). Intelligent transportation systems. International Conference on Modern Research.
  7. Jabbari, S., Kakavand, E. & Roshan, S.M. (2012). Evaluation of adaptability of intra-urban transportation systems with intelligent systems to enhance urban safety. 11th International Transportation and Traffic Conference of Iran, Tehran, March 21. [Persian]
  8. Jafari, N. (2015). The role of intelligent transportation systems (ITS) in solving monitoring and management problems in urban transportation. 2nd International Conference on Research in Engineering, Science, and Technology, March 21. [Persian]
  9. Jafari-Haghighatpour, P., Majid, M., Piran, M. & Berenjkargourabi, A. (2022). Presenting a process architecture model for intelligent transportation systems. 2nd International Conference on Civil Engineering, Urban Planning, Architecture, and Environment. [Persian]
  10. Jiriayi-Sharahi, M., Azizi-Pour, M. & Vafaee-Rad, A. (2019). The role of intelligent transportation in urban management, planning, and development. 4th National Conference on New Ideas in Engineering, Rasht. [Persian]
  11. Joumard R., Gudmundsson H. (2010). Indicators of environmental sustainability in transport. Les collections de L.INRETS. https://backend.orbit.dtu.dk/ws/portalfiles/portal/5719272Joumard, R., Nicolas, j. (2010). Transport project assessment methodology within the framework of sustainable development. Journal of Ecological Indicators, 10: 136–142. https://doi.org/1016/j.ecolind.2009.04.002
  12. Karimi, M. R. (2016). Intelligent transportation systems. 4th International Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development, Tehran. [Persian]
  13. Karkhaneh, S. (2021). Implementation of intelligent transportation systems in the city of Arak. 9th International Conference on Management, Global Trade, Economics, Finance, and Social Sciences. [Persian]
  14. Karkhaneh, S., Subhani, K., Mosafer Mohammad Abadi, M. H. & Ganji, H. (2020). Intelligent transportation as a foundation for creating smart cities. 5th National Conference on Novel Ideas in Engineering and Technology, Rasht. [Persian]
  15. Kashani Jo, K., & Mofidi Shimiarani, S. M. (2009). The evolution of urban transportation theories. City Identity Journal, 3(4), 3-14. [Persian]
  16. Kaveh, A., Karimian Bastani, M. & Miri, G. R. (2024). The role of integrated management in realizing urban intelligent transportation (Case study: Zahedan). Journal of Applied Geographical Sciences, 24(73), 6-46. [Persian]
  17. Kazemi, D. (2010). Recognizing intelligent transportation systems and their role in sustainable urban development. First Conference on Sustainable Urban Development, Kimia Research Group, Tehran, August 7. [Persian]
  18. khalatbari limaki, (2019). Understanding the concept of smart city and its dimensions with the main focus on intelligent transportation.
  19. Khodabandehlu, Abbas. (2021). Evaluation of Intelligent Transportation Systems. 6th International Conference on Research in Science and Engineering and the 3rd International Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development in Asia. Retrieved from: Civilica
  20. Kimanesh, M. R., Sadeghi, M., Khe-Badrudi, S., & Jafari Haqiqatpour, P. (2015). Examining the [Persian] between Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) and public transportation systems (BRT). International Conference on Research in Science and Technology, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, December 14. [Persian].
  1.  
  1. Kunytska, O. & Popov, S. (2023). The role of smart transportation system in a changing environment. International scientific conference management of business process and technological innovations at the current context and in the post-war period, October 10-11, 2023.
  2. Marlon, G.B. (2008). Transportation Infrastructure and Sustainable Development. New Planning Approaches, For Urban Growth, University of California, Irvine, metrostudies, Berkeley, edu.
  3. Mehri, A. K., & Ebrahimi Dehghordi, A. (2017). Planning urban intelligent transportation systems (ITS) with an emphasis on multi-story parking in coastal cities. 3rd Annual Conference on Architecture, Urban Planning, and Urban Management Research, Fars-Shiraz, May 21. [Persian]
  4. Ministry of Roads and Urban Development. (2018). Strategic program for the transportation sector of Iran. Transportation Deputy, Ministry of Roads and Urban Development, Islamic Republic of Iran, June.
  5. Mirza Aghai, S., Mahmoudian Bana, A., Manoochehri, S. & Rezaei Gorgani, A. (2017). The role of intelligent transportation systems in integrating and improving sustainable transportation development. International Conference on New Horizons in Engineering Sciences. [Persian]
  6. Mohammad Zadeh, A., & Abdoli, A. (2017). Analysis and examination of sustainable urban transportation with an emphasis on the development of public transportation. 3rd Annual International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Planning, Shiraz. [Persian]
  7. Moqerpak, A., Ghorbani, F., & Shams Alehi, A. (2020). Intelligent transportation and urban traffic management to achieve smart cities with a development strategy approach (Case study: Hamadan county). International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Development, and Urban Infrastructure Regeneration in Iran, Tehran. [Persian]
  8. Mortazavi Nia, M. (2018). Intelligent transportation systems. 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Decision-Making Sciences, April 9-11, Tehran, Iran. [Persian]
  9. Mousavian, S. A. H. (2010). The necessity of using intelligent transportation systems for sustainable development. First Conference on Organizational Intelligence and Business Intelligence, Tehran, Faculty of Management, Islamic Azad University, Tehran Central Branch, December 28. [Persian]
  10. Mousavian, S. A. H. (2010). The necessity of using intelligent transportation systems for sustainable development. First Conference on Organizational and Business Intelligence, Tehran. [Persian]
  11. Mousavian, S. A. H. (2011). A significant relationship between transportation sustainability and citizens' well-being. Transportation Industry Monthly, 31(313).
  12. Mozani, F. (2022). Examining the impact of intelligent transportation systems (ITS) on smart city transportation management. 8th National Conference on Novel Ideas in Engineering and Technology, Rasht. [Persian]
  13. Nadran, A. (2011). Introduction to urban intelligent transportation systems. Urban Municipalities and Rural Districts Organization, 1st edition, Summer.
  14. Nasir, M. S., & Hendiani, A. (2017). The impact of intelligent transportation systems on traffic management in Tehran. Lahor Scientific-Research Journal, 14(38), 9-37. [Persian]
  15. Nasr, T. (2019). The position of futures studies in developing sustainable urban development scenarios (Case study: Shiraz city). Journal of Urban Management, 55, 189-208. [Persian]
  16. Navadad, V., & Kardaan Halvayi, N. (2007). Intelligent transportation systems. 3rd National Civil Engineering Congress, Tabriz, Tabriz University, April 10. [Persian]
  17. Nikoo, L. (2015). Transportation in Mashhad city and its comparison with smart city Barcelona. 1st National Conference on Urban Management in Iran, Tehran. [Persian]
  18. Oladimeji, D., Gupta, K., Kose, N.A., Gundogan, K., Ge, L., Liang, F. (2023). Smart Transportation: An Overview of Technologies and Applications. Sensors 2023, 23, 3880. https://doi.org/10.3390/ s23083880, doi.org/10.3390/s23083880
  19. Pourhaydar, Mina. (2009). A review of the application of intelligent transportation systems in urban traffic management. 2nd International Conference on Electronic Municipalities, Tehran, Organization of Municipalities and Villages. [Persian]
  20. Ramazanzadeh, Habibollah; Molaei, Ali Reza; & Molaei, Ali Mohammad. (2015). Urban Transportation, Environmental Impacts, and Solutions. Applied Arts Biannual, (6), 55-62. Retrieved from: Semnan University
  21. Ramazanzadeh, Saeed & Shakibaee Far, Davood. (2022). Impact of Intelligent Transportation Systems on Sustainable Urban Development. Raahoor Scientific Quarterly, 11(43), 83-114. Retrieved from: Magiran
  22. Rasouli, Seyed H Qoranjik, A. & Qoranjik, A. (2015). Evaluation of Urban Transportation's Impact on Sustainable Urban Development. 2nd International Conference on Modern Research in Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development. Retrieved from: Civilica
  23. Rezania, K., Raftari, M., Rezania, M. & Mousavi, S. (2017). Transportation and Sustainable Urban Development. 1st National Conference on New Approaches in Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development, Khorramabad, Islamic Azad University, Khorramabad Branch, May 11.
  24. Richardson, B. C. (2005). Sustainable transport: analysis frameworks. Journal of Transport Geography, 13(1), 29-39. https://doi.org/1016/j.jtrangeo.2004.11.005
  25. Sahraei, N., Najafi, F., Khedri, A., & Mirzaei, F. (2021). Review of Intelligent Transportation Systems. 6th International Conference on Research in Science and Engineering and the 3rd International Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development in Asia. Retrieved from: Civilica
  26. Sanaei, Ali & Soleimani, E. (2013). Introduction to Urban Intelligent Transportation Management Systems (ITS) and Their Application in Urban Management (Case Study: Miandoab City). 1st Specialized Congress on Urban Management and City Councils, June 21.
  27. Shahi, F. & Jafarzadeh, R. (2012). Technology in Urban and Intercity Transportation: Intelligent Transportation Systems. Silk Road: The Journal of the Ministry of Roads and Urban Development, 17(134), 28-31.
  28. Shen, SH., Xiao, J., He, Y. & Yahya, k. (2024). Construction of Smart Transportation City System Based on Digital Twins. in book: smart Transportation and Smart Cities,
  29. Shokri, A., Sharifi, H. & Ashrafzadeh, A. (2019). A Critique of Intelligent Transportation Systems. 6th National Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development, Tehran.
  30. Soleimanfar, M.A. (2022). The Relationship Between Intelligent Transportation Systems and IoT (ITS & IOT). 4th International Conference on New Ideas in Architecture, Urbanism, Geography, and Sustainable Environment, Mashhad.
  31. Tabili, H., Dehghani, M. & Soltani, M. (2009). The role of urban management in improving traffic and presenting solutions for reducing traffic and increasing safety. First National Conference on Traffic: Safety and Executive Solutions, Kerman, April 20.
  32. Taghvai, Masoud; Sajjadi, Masoud. (2016). Evaluation and analysis of urban sustainable transportation indicators: Case study of Isfahan. Sustainable City Architecture, 4(1), 1-18. [Persian]
  33. Tumlin, J. (2012). Sustainable Transportation Planning: Tools for Creating Vibrant and resilient communities. New Jersey, John Wiley press.
  34. UNEP (2011). Towards a Green Economy: Pathways to Sustainable Development and Poverty Eradication - A Synthesis for Policy Makers. www.unep.org/greeneconomy, France.
  35. Vis Moradi, S. & Shahraki Kiya, A. (2015). Intelligent transportation systems. 3rd National Conference and 1st International Conference on Applied Research in Electrical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering, and Mechatronics, Tehran. [Persian]
  36. Wang, Y. & Hui, Qi. (2012). Research of Intelligent Transportation System Based on the Internet of Things Frame. Wireless Engineering and Technology, 3, 160-166. http://www.SciRP.org/journal/wet, https://doi.org/10.55981/brin.538.c400
  37. Younus, M., Nurmandi, A., Rohrohmana, N. (2023). Smart Transportation System Evolution: a Comprehensive Mapping and Analysis. Journal of World Science, 2 (12), https://jws.rivierapublishing.id/index.php/jws, https://doi.org/10.58344/jws.v2i12.520
  38. Yousefi, M., Haqdadpour, H., & Sabri, A. (2018). Internet of Things in intelligent transportation systems. 1st National Conference on Applied Research in Electrical Sciences, Computer Engineering, and Biomedical Engineering, Shirvan. [Persian]
  39. Zhang, X. (2024). The Current Development and Optimization of Smart Public Transportation in Taiyuan City. Frontiers in Business, Economics and Management, 13(2), https://doi.org/10.55981/brin.538.c500
  40. Zoorbakhsh, M. & Basat-Andaz, Gh. (2018). The Role of Intelligent Transportation Systems in Urban Sustainability. Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development in Islamic Countries, Tabriz