نوع مقاله : مقاله مستخرج از طرح پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Despite the significance of this phenomenon, the existing literature at the intersection of Shiite geopolitics and religious tourism suffers from considerable conceptual dispersion and notable theoretical and methodological ruptures.
First, despite numerous studies on either religious tourism or geopolitics, there is no coherent picture of the intellectual structure of this field including thematic clusters, evolutionary trajectories, research hubs, and interdisciplinary linkages. This conceptual dispersion hinders evidence-based policymaking and the identification of scientific priorities.
Second, a significant portion of international research operates within Western-centric theoretical frameworks that may be inadequate for explaining the distinct characteristics of Shia pilgrimage in regional contexts. Conversely, much of the domestic literature remains confined to conventional tourism theories, paying insufficient attention to the transformation of "symbolic-religious capital" into "geopolitical capital" or to the role of non-state actors, including pilgrims, grassroots networks, and religious institutions. Furthermore, current knowledge in this area has largely adopted one-dimensional approaches—whether cultural, economic, or security-oriented and has neglected the theoretical and methodological synthesis required to explain the transformation of pilgrimage movements into components of soft power. Iliev (2020) emphasizes the need for a postmodern, interdisciplinary approach to analyzing religious tourism as a complexly structured phenomenon. Similarly, the systematic review by Maheshwari and Singh (2026) identifies gaps such as the scarcity of studies and the lack of precise theoretical frameworks as primary research lacunae in this field. Comparative and transnational analyses are also less developed compared to local and national studies, and the dominance of Western-centric approaches in the existing literature has contributed to the neglect of indigenous contexts and multicultural analyses. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the absence of an integrated conceptual framework that links quantitative (scientometric) and qualitative (content analysis and case-study-based) approaches limits the ability to identify growth trajectories and dynamic feedback loops in events such as Arbaeen. Recent research in religious tourism has demonstrated that mixed methods can contribute to identifying conceptual gaps and providing more comprehensive theoretical frameworks. In particular, analyzing feedback loops and organizing mechanisms in pilgrimage tourism requires approaches that can simultaneously address the systemic and experiential dimensions of the phenomenon. This methodological gap poses a serious obstacle to both theoretical development and the formulation of practical policies.
Methodology
This study employs a mixed-methods (quantitative-qualitative) approach within a systematic review framework, integrating scientometric analysis and qualitative systematic review. A total of 226 sources were systematically retrieved from Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, Google Scholar, Lens, and Dimensions (covering the period 1964–2025), as well as Persian-language sources (2010–2026). Co-occurrence networks were mapped using VOSviewer software, and bibliometric indicators were calculated. Qualitative content analysis was conducted in three stages (open, axial, and selective coding) using MAXQDA software on 1,410 initial codes. The study selection and screening process was documented following the PRISMA guidelines.
The scientometric findings revealed that the international literature is broader and more diverse (120 nodes, 350 links, TLS=1450, density=0.04), whereas the Persian-language literature has a smaller yet denser structure (15 nodes, 26 links, TLS=26, density=0.247). The average degree of the external network was 3.8, while that of the internal network was 2.8; modularity for both networks was estimated to be nearly equal, at approximately 0.32. The content analysis further identified six thematic clusters in the Persian sources and eight clusters in the international sources.
Results and Discussion
The findings of this study are consistent with previous bibliometric reviews in the field of religious tourism, including the study by Durán-Sánchez et al. (2018), which analyzed 412 articles from the Web of Science database. The highest number of publications occurred in 2021 (52 articles), and the highest citation count was recorded in 2022 (967 citations). The most cited article was "Forms of Religious Tourism" by Rinschede (1992), and the Annals of Tourism Research was the most cited journal. The present study extends these findings by incorporating Persian-language sources and highlighting the unique characteristics of the Shia pilgrimage literature.
Early studies (e.g., Turner, Rinschede) primarily focused on the anthropological and ritualistic dimensions of pilgrimage, analyzing it largely apart from its political-power context. However, from the 2010s onward, research such as that of Ahmadi (2018) and Ashraf Hovasi (2023) demonstrated that the Arbaeen pilgrimage—due to its massive scale and its connection to transnational Shia identity—has become a focal
point of regional geopolitical rivalries, where "symbolic-religious capital" is tangibly transformed into "negotiable geopolitical capital."
While the bibliometric analysis (via VOSviewer) mapped the broad structural landscape of the field, the systematic review—employing a qualitative meta-synthesis approach—enabled a deeper elucidation of the content of the studies, the identification of methodological trends, and the extraction of concrete findings from each study. Following the PRISMA guidelines and using pre-designed forms, key data from the 226 retrieved sources were extracted, coded, and categorized through qualitative content analysis. Overall, the systematic review confirms and substantiates the findings derived from the scientometric network: the field of religious tourism to the Atabat (particularly Arbaeen) has reached a threshold of theoretical maturity. However, to translate these capabilities into "operational governance models" and "effective cultural diplomacy," it is necessary to move beyond the identified gaps and enter a phase of interdisciplinary modeling grounded in big data and social network analysis.
Conclusion
Drawing on a systematic review of 226 domestic and international sources, this study sought to provide a comprehensive picture of the evolution of the literature on Shiite geopolitics and religious tourism, and to explain the relationship between pilgrimage to the Atabat (holy shrines) and the production of geopolitical weight within an analytical, multi-level framework.
The findings indicate that although the domestic and international literatures overlap across four major periods, the domestic sources have followed the conceptual and thematic trajectory of the international literature with a relative time lag. Furthermore, the identification of 6 thematic clusters in the domestic sources and 8 clusters in the international sources revealed that this field enjoys considerable diversity in terms of theoretical and methodological underpinnings, although this diversity has not yet culminated in conceptual coherence.
In this regard, research gaps were identified at four levels theoretical-conceptual, methodological, content-thematic, and geopolitical highlighting the need to rethink how the Atabat are studied. The most significant contribution of this research is the formulation of a "self-reinforcing cycle" model to explain the relationship between Shiite geopolitics and religious tourism. According to this model, increased pilgrimage inputs including the number of pilgrims, national diversity, infrastructure development, and media proliferation lead to the strengthening of intermediate processes such as social solidarity, cultural exchange, symbolic capital, and institutional networking. These, in turn, generate outputs such as enhanced soft power, increased transnational influence, and elevated Shiite geopolitical weight. These outputs, through positive feedback mechanisms, feed back into reinforcing the inputs. Thus, the Arbaeen pilgrimage and the Atabat are to be understood not merely as devotional phenomena, but as a dynamic and self-reproducing system of power.
کلیدواژهها English