نقد متدولوژیکِ مطالعات شهری با تأکید بر فلسفه رئالیسم انتقادی

نوع مقاله : علمی - پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانشیار جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس، تهران، ایران.

2 استادیار جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشگاه خوارزمی، تهران، ایران.

3 دکترای جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشگاه خوارزمی، تهران، ایران.

چکیده

اهمیت نقش نظریه اجتماعی به‌خوبی خود را در بحث‌های پیرامون نظریه های شهری و منطقه‌ای نشان میدهد. چراکه نمیوان شهر را مستقل از مفهوم جامعه تجسم کرد و نمیتوان از منظر رئالیستی نظریه شهر را از نظریه جامعه جدا کرد. رابطه تنگاتنگ بین نظریه و عمل در فرایند برنامه‌ریزی شهری، نقش مهمی دارد. امروزه رئالیسم انتقادی به‌عنوان یک رویکرد بین‌رشته‌ای به‌ویژه در حوزه مطالعات شهری و منطقه‌ای تفاوت‌های مثبت و معنادار ایجاد کرده است. روش‌شناسی انتقادی این مقاله متأثر از روی بسکار و اندرو سایر به‌شدت اثبات گرایی و عقل‌گرایی انتقادی را مورد نقد قرار می دهد. با ارجاع به فلسفه علم روی بسکار می توان گفت که کار علم جستن و یافتن، یا به بیانی کشف ساختارها و سازوکارهای اصلی در پدیده‌های مورد پژوهش است که به نحوی قانون‌مند عمل می کنند. در این مقاله، رئالیسم انتقادی روی بسکار که با مواضع معرفت‌شناختی رویکردهای غالب و سنتی ازجمله اثبات گرایی ناسازگار است به‌عنوان رویکردی برای برون‌رفت از شکاف نظریه و عمل در مطالعات شهری و منطقه‌ای معرفی می گردد. ازآنجاکه رئالیسم انتقادی هم ساختارها و محدودیت‌های محیطی و هم تصمیم گیران و نیروهای تأثیرگذار در شهر را باهم موردتوجه قرار می-دهد به‌عنوان یک رویکرد دیالکتیکی وکل‌نگر جهت بررسی روابط بین سازمان فضایی اجتماعی شهر و کارگزاران آن، می‌تواند مناسب باشد و با ساماندهی «نظریه برنامه‌ریزی» ارزیابی کیفی از گزینه‌ها و راه‌حل‌های موجود ارائه دهد. مطابق با شناخت‌شناسی رئالیسم انتقادی، نظریه‌ها با میانجیگری شرایط زمانی و مکانی درک می‌شوند و مطالعات شهری و منطقه‌ای به سمت نظریه-هایی سوق داده می‌شود که جنبه هنجاری و ارزشی بیشتری داشته و دوگانگی جوهری و فرایندی را در هم ادغام می‌کنند.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

Metheodoligical criticism on urban studies based on the Philosophy of Critical Realism

نویسندگان [English]

  • Abolfazl Meshkini 1
  • Abolfazl zanganeh 2
  • elham amirhajlou 3
1 tarbiat modares
2 kharazmi university
3 kharazmi university
چکیده [English]

Extended Abstract
Introduction
Today, critical realism as an interdisciplinary approach especially in field of urban and regional studies creates positive and significant differences. Issues of methodology have strong relations with explanation and priority of agency together with theory structures. In this paper, critical realism, that is in contrast with epistemological positions of traditional and predominant approaches of positivism, has been considered as synthetic and dialectical insight to mean theory of urban and regional planning.
 
Methodology
Critical realism allows using of method of natural sciences in social sciences, but rejects positivistic perspective in favor of alternative perspective. In reproductive strategy of critical realism, a theory or explanation comes from by affirmation of existence hypothesized mechanisms and structures that are responsible for development of observable, regular succession. In this strategy, models have essential roles. These are used for abstract description of regular succession or studying events. According to critical realism Paradigm, whatever researches tend to searching causative structures and mechanisms, researches take qualitative and abstract aspect. But if researches tend to concrete events and studying things, mainly researches take quantitative and concrete aspect.
Critical realism presents a methodological perspective which takes a critical stance towards positivism and hermeneutics on the one hand and tries to integrate strong points from both theories of science on the other hand. Contemporary critical realism is formulated by Roy Bhaskar and his like-minded circle of British colleagues. If we take explanation to be the core purpose of science critical realism seems to emphasis thinking instead of experiencing, and especially the process of abstraction from the domains of the actual and the empirical world to the transfactual mechanisms of the real world. This kind of thinking has made Bhaskar talking about ‘transcendental realism’ in his early writings, emphasizing the crossing of the divide between the empirical and the speculative activities of scientific work. This is so because the experienced world of events is not explainable in terms of the empirical facts, but only by way of incorporating non-experienced mechanisms incorporated in objects which may be within or outside our domain of investigation.
In this study, relationships between agents that are producer of result of development classified based on critical realism into two categories and three levels: mechanisms or policies for tourism (the real) provides guidelines for the tourism industry, and agents and stakeholders (the actual), that instructions in different ways to produce different results that have already been experienced in cities (the empirical) explain.
 
Results and Discussion
Comprehensive perspective of city as a system that has the related social, physical, economic and institutional subsystems, is similar to critical realism. Logic of communication which theorized critical realism, help to comprehensive perspective of urban systems (structure) with interrelated subsystems. Of course, when urban systems versus open social systems, are considered as a closed social system, distance from comprehensive of critical realism. Since critical realism take account to both environmental constrains and structures and effective forces and decision-makers, it can be adequate as a integrated approach for studying relation between city sociospatial organization and its agencies, and with organizing ‘planning theory’ provide qualitative appraisal of existing solutions and options. From view point of critical realism, focus is wrong logic, on prediction, universal and objective knowledge, explanatory statistical models and Poperian theory in context of scientific and falsification criteria in comprehensive model. Planning theory examines realities and values as well as tools and goals in connection with each other and not independently. Bhaskar suggest processing planning theory that involves shaping goals and identifying and spreading options, in contrast decision-making paradigm limits right of choice among presented options and predetermined goals (instrumental logic model). Critical realism with dialectic insight between realms of environment and society has created internal relation in shape of new and rooted phenomen. In spite of identifying differences between tow realms, should confirm that their layered and internal linkages connect in the fundamental unity to each other. However, unification in light of lawful mechanisms and structures which act in form of paraphenomen or antiphenomen, aim of urban and regional studies. Empiricism and positivism study sociospacial phenomena by pure focus on observable events generally. However, as critical realism suggests, causative interpretation behind the sociospatial events are not reveal by research method of empiricism and positives, because they focus only on observable and regular events. In critical realism, we see some instances of ‘planning theory’ that aim to mixing and creating relation between different combatting realms.
 
Conclusion
Critical realism provides a dialectic direction for reorganizing of planning theory and referred to integrated frameworks that mix abstract and concrete concepts like as global and local, appearance and content, geography (place) and history (time) rather than they treat as bottleneck. Dialectic factor that explains practices between individuals and emphasizes on universality of society, is necessary means for widespread social transformation and critical realism appear in realm of social practice of individuals and brings about self- consciousness and liberty of humans. Moreover, as a socio-special component, it awares us about theory of regional development. Critical realism challenges paradigms of up to bottom development; these paradigms are regional drivers for development and regional diversity hidden influences of global and national changes, as well. This paper showed that instead abstract understanding of planning theories and categorizing these to essence and process according to epistemology of critical realism that practice-theory interaction is its sensitivity, theories are understanded by mediation of temporal and spatial position, and urban and regional studies are leaded to theories that have much more normative aspect and integrate essence-process dualism to each other.


کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Critical Realism
  • Roy Bhaskar
  • Planning Theory
  • Urban and Regional Studies
  • Theory and Practice
  1. حاجی­نژاد، علی؛ پایدار، ابوذر و صادقی، خدیجه (1393). میزان موفقیت طرحهای هادی روستایی از دیدگاه مردم و مسئولان (مورد: شهرستان رشتخوار)، جغرافیا (فصلنامه علمی- پژوهشی و بین­المللی انجمن علمی اجغرافیایی ایران)، دوره 12، شماره 43، صص. 103-81.
  2. حیدری­ساربان، وکیل و یاری­حصار، ارسطو (1396). عوامل موثر در بهبود سرزندگی اجتماعی از دیدگاه روستاییان مطالعه موردی: شهرستان اردبیل، برنامه­ریزی منطقه­ای، دوره 7، شماره 25، صص. 53-41.
  3. زنگنه، مهدی؛ صفایی، محمدجواد و سمیعی، مریم (1398). کنکاشی بر رویکرد توانمند سازی جهت ساماندهی سکونتگاههای غیر رسمی (نمونه موردی: شهرتربت حیدریه)، جغرافیا (فصلنامه علمی -پژوهشی و بین­المللی انجمن جغرافیایی ایران)، دوره 17، شماره 62، صص. 205-191.
  4. صادقی، خدیجه؛ بذرافشان، جواد؛ حاجی­نژاد، علی و یاسوری، مجید (1399). بررسی عوامل موثر بر شادابی و سرزندگی خانوارهای روستایی (مورد مطالعه: شهرستان فومن)، پژوهش­های روستایی تهران، دوره 11، شماره 2، صص. 269-250.
  5. محمدیان منصور، صاحبه؛ گل­خندان، داود؛ خوانساری، مجتبی و گل­خندان، ابوالقاسم (1394). تحلیل عوامل اجتماعی- اقتصادی موثر بر شادی ( یک تحلیل اقتصادسنجی با در نظر گرفتن محدودیت­های مذهبی)، برنامه­ریزی رفاه و توسعه اجتماعی، شماره 25، صص. 163-125.
  6. Mohammadian Mansour, S., Golkhandan, D., Khansari, M. & Golkhandan, A. (2015). Analysis of socio-economic factors affecting happiness (an econometric analysis considering religious constraints), Welfare and Social Development Planning, No. 25, pp. 125-163. [Persian].
  7. Zanganeh, M., Safaei, M. J. & Samiei, M. (2019). Exploration on empowerment approach to organizing informal settlements (Case study: Torbat-e Heydarieh), Geography (Iranian Journal of International Geographical Research), Vol. 17, No. 62, PP. 191-205. [Persian].
  8. Hajiinejad, A., Paiedar, A. & Sadeghi, Kh. (2014). The success rate of rural pilot projects from the perspective of people and officials (Case: Rashtkhar city), Geography (Quarterly Journal of the Iranian Geographical Scientific Association), Vol. 12, No. 43, PP. 81-103. [Persian].
  9. Berry, B. & Okulicz-Kozaryn, A. (2013). An Urban-Rural Happiness Gradient, Urban Geography, 2011, Vol 32, No. 6, PP. 871–883.
  10. Çağlayan-Akay, E. & Timur, B. (2017). Kadınların ve erkeklerin mutluluğunu etkileyen faktörlerin genelleştirilmiş sıralı logit modeli ile analizi. Sosyal Bilimler Araştırma Dergisi, Vol. 6, No. 3, PP. 88-105.
  11. Combs, E. & Xia, Y. (2000). Increasing Older Populations and Rural Community Happiness: The Role of Housing, Housing and Society, Vol. 27, No. 1, PP. 43-54.
  12. Cook, CH. Bruin, M. Yust, B. Crull, S. Shelley, M. Laux, SH. Memken, J. Niemeyer, SH. & White, B.J. (2009). Evidence of a Housing Decision Chain in Rural Community Happiness, Rural Sociology, Vol. 74, No. 1, PP. 113–137.
  13. Cummins, R. A. (2005) Moving from the qualityof life concept to a theory. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, Vol. 49, No. 10, pp. 699-705.
  14. Diener, ED. (2007). Subjective well-being & peace. J Social Issues, Vol. 63, PP. 421-440.
  15. Heidarisarban, V. & Yariyesar, A. (2017). Factors affecting the improvement of social Happiness from the perspective of the villagers Case study: Ardabil city, regional planning, Vol. 7, No. 25, PP. 41-53. [Persian].
  16. Hong-ngam, J., Ayuwat, D., Saranrittichai K. & Auraiampai, N. (2022). Factors affecting the level of happiness through economics status: evidences from elderly in the northeastern region of Thailand, International Journal of Business and Globalisation, Vol. 29, No. 1, PP. 116-134.
  17. Ml. (2011). rural community Happiness.the cases of fort benton, montana and watford city, north dakota.Official Graduation Semester May 2011, pp.2,4.
  18. Johnson, J. & Wood, A. M. (2017). Integrating Positive and Clinical Psychology: Viewing Human Functioning as Continua from Positive to Negative Can Benefit Clinical Assessment, Interventions and Understandings, Cognitive Therapy and Research, Vol. 41, No. 2, PP.  335-349.
  19. Karaaslan, K. C. (2021). Analysis of Factors Affecting Individuals' Sources of Happiness with Multinomial Logistic Model, Journal of Measurement and Evaluation in Education and Psychology, Vol. 12, No. 3, PP. 286-302.
  20. Kerstetter, D., Shen, X., Yi, X., Pan, B., Zhang, G., Li, R., Gao, J. & Li, G. (2022). Sources of Happiness: A Mixed Methods Phenomenological Study of Factors Affecting Residents’ Subjective Wellbeing in Shenzhen, China, Psychological Reports, Vol. 125, No. 1, PP. 167- 199.
  21. Kuliesis, G. & Pareigiene, L. (2014). Susisiekimo Infrastrukturos Vystymosi Tendencijos Lietuvos Regionuose, Management Theory and Studies for Rural Business and Infrastructure Development, Vol. 36, No. 2, PP. 348- 353.
  22. Kyung Jo, H. Kyoung Kim, H. & Jeong, J. (2020). Factors Affecting Happiness Among Rural Residents: A Cross Sectional Survey, Community Mental Health Journal, Vol. 56, PP. 915- 924.
  23. Medvedev, O. N. & Landhuis, C. E. (2018). Exploring constructs of well-being, happiness and quality of life. Peer Journal, Vol. 6, 4903.
  24. Miñarro, S., Reyes-García, V., Aswani, S., Selim, S., Barrington-Leigh, C. P., & Galbraith, E. D. (2021). Happy without money: Minimally monetized societies can exhibit high subjective well-being. PLOS ONE, Vol. 16, No. 1, PP. 1-15.
  25. Muthuri, R. N. D. K., Senkubuge, F., & Hongoro, C. (2020). Determinants of happiness among healthcare professionals between 2009 and 2019: a systematic review. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, Vol. 7, No. 1, PP. 1-14.
  26. Nawijn, J., Marchand, M. A., Veenhoven, R. & Vingerhoets. J. (2010). Vacationers Happier, but Most not Happier After a Holiday, Applied Research in Quality of Life,Vol. 5, No. 1, PP. 35-47.
  27. P. C, Veldhuijzen Van Zanten. J. J, Ntoumanis. N, Metsios. G. S, Yu. G. & Duda. J. l. (2015). Measuring the positive psychological wellbeing of people with rheumatoid arthritis: a cross-sectional validation of the subjective Happiness scale, Vol. 17, No 312, PP. 1-7.
  28. Sadeghi, KH., Bazrafshan, J., Hajinejad, A. & Yasouri, M. (2016). A Study of Factors Affecting the Happiness and Happiness of Rural Households (Case Study: Fooman County), Tehran Rural Research, Vol. 11, No. 2, PP. 250- 269. [Persian].
  29. Veenhoven, R. (2018). Co-development of Happiness Research: Addition to ‘‘Fifty Years after the Social Indicator Movemen, Soc Indic Res, 135:1001- 1007.